Real Grass vs. Artificial Turf: Which is Better for Phoenix Yards?

How To Make The Right Choice for Your Situation

Over the years, I've had a significant number of clients move here to Arizona primarily for our amazing weather. They arrive excited about the opportunity to use their outdoor space year-round, but one thing they quickly discover is that landscaping methods in Arizona are pretty unique compared to most other states.

One question I consistently get from these new transplants- and increasingly from established homeowners- is whether they should choose real grass or artificial turf. The newcomers often feel overwhelmed by the maintenance demands of keeping a real lawn alive in the desert, while my long-time clients have grown tired of the regular upkeep and yearly ritual of scalping and overseeding. Both groups wonder if artificial turf is the solution they're looking for.

After more than three decades in the Arizona landscaping industry, I've installed both options countless times, and I've developed some insights that might help you make this decision. Let me start by saying there's no universal "right" answer here- what works perfectly for your friend in the Ahwatukee Foothills might be a disaster for your home in east Mesa. However, after working on projects ranging from small backyard makeovers to sprawling Scottsdale or Circle G estates, I can share what I've learned about both options and help you determine which might be the better fit for your specific situation.

The Real Story About Keeping Your Grass Green Year Round in Phoenix

When I first started in this business back in the '90s, overseeding was pretty much the only game in town if you wanted green grass year-round. The process is straightforward enough- in September you dry out your summer Bermuda grass then in early October mow it down to almost nothing. Next, you lay down ryegrass seed, water like crazy, and pray for good seed germination.

Okay so that may be a super simplified version of how the grass transition take place but here's what most people don't realize: successful overseeding in our Arizona desert climate is more art than science. There are some tried and true guidelines to follow for best results, and a timetable to stick by throughout the process but at the end of the day, you're still working with the uncertainties of mother nature. Miss the ideal window for drying out your summer grass and you could thwart your chances for a successful winter lawn. Go skimpy on your seed or throw it down too late in the season and you could be looking at bald patches for months.

The truth is, overseeding done correctly can give you that beautiful, lush green lawn from November through March. And, there's nothing quite like the feel of cool ryegrass under your feet during a mild Phoenix winter. But here's where it gets tricky– you're essentially growing two different types of grass in the same space every single year, and they have completely different needs.

The Good Parts of Having Real Grass and Overseeding:

• Can be comparatively inexpensive upfront, especially if you DIY your annual scalping and overseeding (though costs do add up annually)

• Natural grass feel and appearance, especially in the winter

• Works well if you're committed to the maintenance schedule

• Can be satisfying if you enjoy lawn care as a hobby

• Makes the perfect surface for those who love going barefoot and enjoy grounding/earthing

  
  

The Challenges I See Every Year:

• Water usage to keep your summer lawn green and extra watering during establishment of your winter grass (we're talking 3-5 times daily watering for weeks in the fall)

• Timing is everything when transitioning your lawns– overseeding too early and your Bermuda fights the ryegrass or fries in the heat, too late and you get poor germination and a thin, patchy lawn

• Requires weather conditions to cooperate for best success

• Expenses to maintain both summer and winter grass can be higher than most homeowners estimate

  
  

I've seen too many frustrated homeowners who work for months to establish a green lawn, only to have to go through the whole process over again when the seasons change.

My Experience with Artificial Turf Evolution

Now, let me tell you about artificial turf – and I'm not talking about that plastic carpet stuff from the 1980s that looked like it belonged on a mini-golf course. The technology has completely changed, and frankly, some of the products we install now are so realistic that neighbors will drive by and not even realize that what they're looking at isn't actually real grass.

I was actually pretty skeptical about artificial turf when it started coming on the scene here in the Valley in early 2000's. I remember installing one of my first artificial lawns in Chandler and honestly, it looked decent but definitely artificial. The homeowner was happy because he didn't have to deal with the mowing and overseeding anymore, but you could tell upon inspection that it wasn't real grass.

Here's the thing though – I was dealing with my own grass problems at home. I had real grass in both my front and backyard for years, but eventually switched to artificial turf in both areas. Why? The weekly and annual maintenance wasn't always getting done, and the grass under my large shade trees would no longer grow properly due to lack of sun. In the front yard I kept getting fungal diseases that were a nightmare to deal with. Even after completely removing the top few inches of grass and laying new sod, the problems kept coming back.

Fast forward to today, and the difference is remarkable. The artificial turf we install now comes in a variety of colors, has different blade shapes, multiple colors woven throughout, and a natural-looking thatch layer. Not only that but it is made to last for years without fading and is both pet and kid friendly . As someone who has had artificial turf in my own backyard for over 15 years, it's easy to recommend it to my clients because I know how well it holds up.

One of the most satisfying by-products of installing artificial turf is the number of phone calls we receive from our clients' neighbors afterward. Once they witness firsthand how much easier the maintenance is- no more weekly mowing, seasonal overseeding, or battling fungal diseases- and see that beautiful year-round lush green color, they want the same transformation for their own lawns. It's the best endorsement we could ask for.

What Makes Modern Artificial Turf Different?:

• Advanced drainage systems that handle heavy monsoon rains and pet waste

• UV protection that prevents fading in our intense Arizona sun

• Antimicrobial infill options that reduce odors

• Multiple blade heights and colors for realistic appearance

• Kid and pet friendly materials that are safe for the whole family

• Ideal for use in hard-to-grow areas like under trees or between walkways

While our local turf supplier offers a 15-year warranty on their products, well-made turf that is properly maintained can last upwards of 20+ years. In all my years of installing artificial turf lawns, I've only ever had 2 clients who actually needed to use their turf warranties because the product didn't hold up to their satisfaction. That's a pretty impressive track record!

But here's where I need to be completely straight with you – artificial turf isn't a magical solution either. I've seen some mistakes over the years and learned some hard lessons about proper installation techniques specific to our climate.

The Honest Drawbacks of Artificial Turf:

Now as much as I am a fan of using artificial turf in Arizona, there are definitely some drawbacks that you'll want to be aware of when making the decision for your lawn. Some important things to note:

• Turf can get warm during our hottest summer months which means pets and kids will want to refrain from going barefoot during the hottest parts of the day

• For families with multiple large pets who consistently use the same spot, odor can become an issue and requires periodic cleaning

• You'll need to blow off leaves and debris rather than just mowing over them like you would with real grass

• Higher upfront investment compared to sod or overseeding

• It's not very easy to DIY- ground preparation and proper installation are essential to get the longevity out of artificial turf

  
  

The pet situation is worth mentioning specifically since so many of our clients have dogs. The drainage system on the turf handles pet waste well, and occasional cleaning with an enzyme cleaner usually takes care of any odor issues. But, if you have several large dogs who all prefer the same corner of the yard, just know you might need to clean that area more frequently.

The Real Costs to Real Grass vs. Artificial Turf

Let's talk money, because this is where most homeowners get surprised. With real grass you're looking at annual costs for:

• The initial turf install for your summer grass

• Scalping and cleanup (if you hire it out) for preparation to lay your winter grass

• Seed and soil amendments

• Regular watering

• Increased water bills during seed establishment and throughout the winter

• Fertilizer and maintenance

• Equipment maintenance if you mow/blow yourself or maintenance costs if you hire out

  
  

  

Compared to real grass, artificial turf does have a higher upfront investment – in Arizona you're typically looking at $6-$10+ per square foot installed, depending on the product quality and site conditions. But here's what most people don't calculate: the water savings alone can be substantial over time. I have clients who've cut their water bills by several hundred dollars after installing artificial turf.

I typically tell my clients that they can recoup the cost of their artificial turf investment within 3-4 years of installation. Each year after that is just money in your pocket. That's not unusual here in the Valley where water rates keep climbing.

Climate Reality Check for Phoenix Area

Something transplants to the Phoenix area learn very quickly is that maintaining a green summer lawn in Arizona can be tricky! And every year, it seems like you work on greening up your summer lawn for months just to reach September and have to dry it out for the scalping and overseeding cycle of the winter grass. Some years, it may all work out and then others- along comes a rouge rainstorm and all your freshly seeded areas can be washed away in a matter of minutes. Don't even get me started on the crazy bird feasting that happens the moment the seeds touch the ground.

With artificial turf, weather becomes irrelevant. Monsoon rains? No problem, proper drainage handles it. Heat waves in July and August? The turf stays green and usable. Dust storms? A quick rinse and you're back to perfect-looking grass.

The Maintenance Reality of Real Grass

If you're someone who enjoys weekend lawn care, real turf might be more appealing to you. But be realistic about what you're signing up for. Summer grass can be fairly easy to maintain once you've got it looking nice but during establishment of your winter rye seed in the fall, you'll need to be on your toes. Not only will you be overseeing a pretty frequent watering schedule for the first several weeks but you'll need to keep a close eye on your lawn. Too many hungry birds left to feast, a wandering dog or hurried delivery person walking over your seedlings and your new lawn can be ruined just like that.

For busy families – which describes most of our clients – artificial turf eliminates the guesswork. No more worrying about vacation timing around overseeding schedules. No more panic when the sprinkler system breaks during critical establishment periods.

I installed artificial turf for a family in Queen Creek who travels extensively throughout the year. They told me it was life-changing to come home to a perfect lawn regardless of how long they'd been gone.

Making the Right Choice for Your Situation

After 30+ years in the landscape construction industry, I can usually predict which option will work better for a particular homeowner within the first few minutes of our consultation. Here's what I look for:

Real Turf and Overseeding might work better if you:

• Genuinely enjoy hands-on lawn care or you plan to hire out regular landscape maintenance services

• Have a reliable irrigation system and consistent water pressure

• Don't mind annual expense and time investment

• Have realistic expectations about results

  
  

Artificial turf typically makes more sense if you:

• Want predictable, consistent results

• Travel frequently or have busy schedules

• Are looking for long-term value despite higher upfront costs

• Want to reduce water usage and maintenance time

• Want the look in areas where real grass could be hard to maintain

Professional Installation Makes All the Difference

Whether you choose real grass or artificial turf, proper installation is crucial. Especially for fall rye grass overseeding, the timing, soil preparation, and irrigation management can make or break your results. [If you're considering the overseeding route, check out our detailed guide on proper scalping and overseeding techniques for Arizona lawns.] Click Here.

For artificial turf, the base preparation, drainage system, and proper stretching are everything. I've seen too many DIY installations that look great initially but develop problems within a year because the base wasn't properly prepared or the turf wasn't correctly stretched. Also, many homeowners don't realize that there is a wide range of qualities and chances are, if you grabbed a role of artificial turf off the shelf from a discount store, it's probably not going to last more than a couple of summers.

My Honest Recommendation

After installing both options hundreds of times throughout the Phoenix Metro area, I find myself recommending artificial turf more often than not. The technology has simply gotten too good, and the long-term benefits usually outweigh the higher initial investment.

That said, I still do install plenty of real turf projects for clients who prefer natural grass and are committed to the maintenance requirements. The key is being honest about your expectations and lifestyle.

If you're considering either option for your Gilbert, Chandler, Mesa, or anywhere else in the Valley home, I'd encourage you to get a professional consultation. Every yard is different, and factors like soil conditions, drainage, sun exposure, and your family's usage patterns all play into making the right decision.

Ready to Explore Your Options?

Whether you're leaning toward real grass or artificial turf, the most important thing is making an informed decision based on your specific situation and long-term goals. I've helped hundreds of Phoenix area families transform their outdoor spaces, and I'd be happy to share my experience with your project.

If you're in the Phoenix Metro area and ready to explore which option makes the most sense for your yard, reach out to us for a free consultation. We'll walk your property, discuss your goals and lifestyle, and help you make the choice that you'll be happy with for years to come.

Click Here to Schedule a Free Consultation